“You haven’t seen it,” said Abbey. “It’s cute.”
I felt her fingers slowly rubbing over and around my sphincter. She spit on her fingers and the movements felt much smoother. She probed me with one finger. “That’s not enough,” she said.
I sensed her reaching between her legs for more lubricant. The next time she touched my rectum it was much smoother. A finger began to probe the center of my sphincter. I held my breath. “Help me here,” said Abbey. “Relax.”
I took a deep breath, exhaled completely, and pushed back against her finger. Her finger slipped inside my ass up to the first knuckle. “Oh,” sung Abbey. “Nice.”
“Nice?” I questioned.
“Take another deep breath,” Abbey instructed.
I took a deep breath. Before I could exhale, Abbey pushed her finger all the way inside me. I gasped. “Wait,” I pleaded.
“Too late,” said Abbey. She began to wiggle her finger inside me and found a large lump in front. She prodded the lump. “What’s that?” she asked.
“My prostate,” I told her. “And don’t do that.”
“Why not?” she asked as she prodded my prostate again.
“It’s … it’s like I’m going to cum,” I explained.
“She poked again. “You mean it’s like a ‘go’ button?” she asked.
“Go, cum. What’s the difference? Either way, I feel the pressure,” I challenged.
“Let’s see,” suggested Abbey. She reached for my cock with her other hand, stroked it a few times and pressed on my prostate. A small volume of semen leaked out of my cock and my erection hardened. That’s when someone knocked on the bedroom door.
“Should we answer it?” asked Abbey.
“Why not?” I said. “Yes,” I called.
The door opened. It took Mia a moment to process the scene in front of her. “Is your finger where I think it is?” she asked Abbey.
“It is and should see what I found,” Abbey told her.
“Enough,” I squawked and lurched forward while simultaneously squeezing Abbey’s finger from my ass. “What do you want?” I asked Mia.
“I’m your wife,” Mia said. “I thought it would be nice if we ended the night together. Robin is with Donte and Jim is waiting for Abbey.”
Abbey kissed my ass. “Next time,” she said.
“We had and agreement,” I reminded her.
“I guess that’ll have to wait until next time too,” she responded.
Abbey left the room and Mia closed the door. “What was that all about?” she asked.
“Some other time,” I told her. “Come here. I need you with me,” I said.
Mia climbed on the bed, pushed me over and kissed me. “Disappointed with Robin and Abbey?” she asked.
“Not at all,” I told her honestly. “But neither of them can match having my Mia in my bed,” I said.
“Aahh,” she said. “Do you want to fuck me?”
“It would be my pleasure,” I confessed.
“Make it mine too,” Mia asked as she rolled over on the bed and pulled me on top of her.
By nine Saturday morning, all six of us were gathered in the kitchen. We were in various states of dress. The men had found and put on their trousers and shirts. The women were only wearing their panties. Topless seemed to be the appropriate dress of the day.
“Just panties?” Donte asked Robin.
“Why not?” she responded. “I’m comfortable. There’s nothing left to hide and I’m only wearing panties because I’m leaking thanks to the three of you. Actually, I’m considering dressing like this whenever we’re all together.”